the prestige book vs movie reddit
If you ask me, it is exactly what Inception should have been. I think if I were stranded on a dessert island and HAD to pick one, I'd pick The Prestige, but Inception is still right there with it for me. It is the death of Mal that is keeping him from his children, not for any other reason. The Margos get a little magical in this listener-suggested book to movie adaptation that features sleight of hand, lots of dead birds, women in jeopardy and a twist ending you either did or didn’t see coming a mile away. The story of a rapidly escalating feud between rival magicians in the 1800s, The Prestige proved Christopher Nolan wasn't a director to ignore. Two young men devoted to an illusion. save. It's the same idea but with a con. He has a twin brother he keeps hidden away. hide. Then I watched the movie a second time and realized they set it up perfectly, and I even felt stupid for missing it the first time. Doing that means watching the movie again and again, looking for even more-expertly concealed clues to help unwrap the mystery and discover the truth. Now The Prestige book and film are very different. And the "puzzle" in The Prestige was actually worth figuring out. Book Borden was the asshole; I liked book Angier, he was far more sympathetic and talented. Next, John Cutter explains the form of an illusion to a little girl. This rarely happens! I also enjoy the axe more than the mallet, it seems more realistic. Give me my book back, thank you very much. Nevertheless, much like the magic trick at the centre of Christopher Priest's The Prestige, the original version is more inventive for having been the first and all the more enjoyable for not having technology of movie magic as an aid to bolster the haunting tale. In which the books vs. movies review is usurped. Cinematically, every shot was gorgeous. The movie is a magic trick by Nolan on the audience. Abracadabra! However, you should know that the movie is based on a book of the same title which won a World Fantasy Award, and while events diverge a fair amount, the book's shelved in fantasy for a reason.. Press J to jump to the feed. Penn Jillette (Penn & Teller) Reviews Magic Tricks in The Prestige, Arrested Development and More - Duration: 11:36. Movie Review | 'The Prestige' Two Rival Magicians, and Each Wants the Other to Go Poof. The characters were more interesting and not as shallow as those from Inception. It was a tenser experience with much more compelling motivations to drive the characters forward. Exactly. Brilliant. His first appearance through the electrical arcs is my favourite single shot of the film. It is epistolary in structure; that is, it purports to be a collection of real diaries that were kept by the protagonists and later collated. 0. Most movies do their thing in 1.5–3 hours. It was just brilliant. While I certainly don’t think so, I do recognize the sheer brilliance that the film is. If you haven't seen the movie The Prestige, then you should not read the notes behind the cut.Really. In fact, I don't even entirely agree with my post (it's a little harsh on Inception), I just wanted to get the ball rolling. But the ending leaves you with no doubt as to what you have just watched. How does an actor go from deathly skinny in one role to superhero buff back to deathly skinny in just a matter of months? Two young men who never intended to hurt anyone. I love The Prestige and I actually re-watched it quite recently. In an interview Nolan himself revealed the true ending to Inception: “The important thing is that Cobb’s not looking at the top. The film was more entertaining, and not at all creepily disturbing like the novel. While some might feel a sense of frustration at the source material being overshadowed, I think that in this case the book and the movie actually act as perfect companions for one another. Or at the beginning of the movie when Angier is reading Borden's journal: "We were two young men at the start of a great career. So you have finished watching Inception and you can now spark up the debate over the spinning top; was Cobb in fact in reality? For example. The Prestige Book vs Movie. The Prestige follows a rivalry waged between one-time partners and stage illusionists Robert Angier (Hugh Jackman) and Alfred Borden (Christian Bale). New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, News & Discussion about Major Motion Pictures, Press J to jump to the feed. The summary below contains spoilers. The Margos get a little magical in this listener-suggested book to movie adaptation that features sleight of hand, lots of dead birds, women in jeopardy and a twist ending you either did or didn’t see coming a mile away. By Jack Otway Published Jan 05, 2020. Join & Discussion about English movie The Prestige. It's sleight of hand with editing. Book Vs Movie Podcast “The Prestige” The 1995 novel by Christopher Priest versus the Christopher Nolan film. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. is superb. The Prestige NYT Critic's Pick Directed by Christopher Nolan Drama, Mystery, Sci-Fi, … Meet new friends online & Invite other friends to Share your comments & thoughts with about The Prestige movie The most common story structure is the 3 Act structure: Act 1 (The Pledge) is where you are given a character/scenario that is normal, Act 2 (The Turn) that world of the normal is flipped on it's head and we see how the main character and supporting characters live and grow in this new world, and Act 3 (The Prestige) the problems and obstacles for our main character that were introduced at the break into Act 2 are resolved and everything goes back to normal but the main character remains forever and irrevocably changed (for better or worse). Darn you Nolan, I'll never be able to watch any new movies with you making me re-watch yours. I love both films, but Inception isn't just some summer blockbuster... One of the greatest things Inception did is convince people they know the ending to Inception when they may actually have missed it almost entirely. Oh crap. Rotten Tomatoes, home of the Tomatometer, is the most trusted measurement of quality for Movies & TV. ‘The Prestige’ Movie Summary. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, when the young boy asks: "Where's his brother?" Not through exercise and diet. It is because people who see the movie do not actually get the movie. The Prestige is a 2006 mystery thriller film directed by Christopher Nolan, written by Nolan and his brother Jonathan, based on the 1995 novel of the same name by Christopher Priest.It follows Robert Angier and Alfred Borden, rival stage magicians in London at the end of the 19th century.Obsessed with creating the best stage illusion, they engage in competitive one-upmanship, with fatal results. The book follows a fragmented but engaging story of two magicians in a fierce battle to outdo each other and to find out one anothers secrets. The The Prestige Community Note includes chapter-by-chapter summary and analysis, character list, theme list, historical context, author biography and quizzes written by community members like you. At times confusing, both movie and the book. Unlike the movie the book begins in the present and the story is almost a journal or diary of both the protagonists life. I liked how the film got rid of the really weird stuff. EDIT: more dark* 45 comments. And it wasn't just a case of me going in with low expectations, I really did find it engrossing. I just realized that was a subtle nod from Nolan. In this video i review The Prestige by Christopher Priest the first of my Booktuber Recommends Books. They gave away a huge part of the movie in the very first shot, with all the hats in the forest. I thought the atmosphere in the movie was more darker than the book. He doesn’t care.”. Information wasn't left out because it would "give away the ending," information was merely left out to confuse the audience, making them feel like the movie is intelligent. The Prestige Book vs Movie Add A Difference . Most of you assumed that the entire premise of Inception was to plant an idea in the mind of Robert Fischer, the heir to his fathers company. Cutter insists that the only way the trick is possible is with a double, but Angier refuses to believe it. yes, BUT, Inception is not only telling this story of corporate espionage, it's also telling you how movies are made and how people easily believe all these concepts when presented in a film. When you watch it again, the bit where Bale's character tries to console the boy who cried at the birdcage trick and the boy says 'But where's his brother?' I just saw the Prestige for the first time a week ago. Cobb is the target of Inception from the very beginning... Everything else in the film is merely a means to an end. Also, I get chills at the ending when it transitions back to the hats in the field while Michael Cain is narrating the ending. The Prestige is a 1995 novel by British writer Christopher Priest.It tells the story of a prolonged feud between two stage magicians in late 1800s England. Inception was confusing for the sake of being confusing: there was no reason to its twists and turns. So many things about it make it great; from the ending being revealed half-way through when the young boy asks: "Where's his brother?" They are both fantastic movies. Here You Going To Find A List With The Best Movies And Tv Shows Streaming Sites Free No Account … The first time I saw it I didn't like the ending. The Prestige was far more intelligent, in my opinion, and I'm hoping to watch it a fourth time this week to master its intricate hidden details once and for all. Here's everything coming to streaming on Netflix, Hulu, and Amazon Prime Video in February—including new Netflix originals, Chloe Zhao's latest, and more. However, I re-watched The Prestige and was blown away by the drama. What I love about The Prestige though is that it's literally a magic trick with film! The movie is set up so that you watch Angier become obsessed with knowing the true nature of Borden's trick. Let's get one thing out of the way: I preferred the movie. Vanity Fair Recommended for you Of course, book has such a interesting story, and I liked it. Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban: 10 Things The Movie Changed From The Book. made for an interesting reading experience. In the film, the very first thing the audience learns of are the three components of a magic trick: the promise, the turn, and the prestige. It was a tenser experience with much more compelling motivations to drive the characters forward. Was thinking about getting the S.F masterworks ebook if it ever goes on sale for cheap. The audacity to give away the whole film at that point and the confidence to know 98% of the audience won't pick it up is amazing. More importantly, the movie succeeded in obscuring plotholes where the novel did not. I think they are great companion pieces. As an audience member you also want to believe that something more is going on; you want to be fooled. It made you think twice about reality. The overarching theme of obsession is an intriguing on by itself, but I just found the story to be very engrossing. The Prestige . It is our intent and purpose to foster and encourage in-depth discussion about all things related to books, authors, genres, or publishing in a safe, supportive environment. share. Both are great and I enjoyed them a lot. The Prestige is Christopher Nolan's way of revealing the truth about Christian Bale. I'm sure this has been said before, but given that it's a story of doppelgangers and neverending feuds, it's fitting to say that they are both as worthy of being called The Prestige as the other. Surprisingly, I would say the Shining. More importantly, the movie succeeded in obscuring plotholes where the novel did not. He does not care about the top any longer, because he has let go of his guilt. Didn't like how they switched book protagonist/antagonist in the film. It's far more impactful as a novel. Add/Edit a Difference. having watched the film first, this messed with me bc i started, as you say, invested with borden as the good guy and that idea got wrecked over time. EDIT 2: I've never posted to /r/movies so I didn't know if this place was as susceptible to shitstorms as much as a place like r/gaming, so let me just be clear that I think both movies are very very good, The Prestige just appeals more to me (and, if I may be so bold, I really do think it is a bit more intelligent, but that's my opinion). Ariadne is a very important piece to understanding the real ending to Inception; in The Myth of Theseus and the Minotaur, Princess Ariadne gives Theseus a sword to kill the Minotaur and a ball of red string (thus Ariadne wearing a red sweater) so Theseus can find his way back out of the Labyrinth after. Inception did better at the box office because it was a fun summer action movie that convinced people it was more intelligent than it really was. Unlike many mystery movies, The Prestige is a film that begs its audience to go back and watch again, to see how obvious clues unfold, and how more subtle clues are revealed. You should watch the Brothers Bloom. The Prestige. Many believe ‘The Prestige’ is the best Christopher Nolan film. "The movie is good, but doesn't capture the experience of reading the book. Limited Storytelling Time Perhaps I missed a “pallid shape of academic goose flesh” in the Brave New World movie because of time constraints. Re-watching. It was better in almost every way. Same when Cutter says of Root, "When I'm through with him, he could be your brother," and Angier argues with, "I don't need him to be my brother, I need him to be me.". I agree. So, here are 10 things that did not make it into the film. The book is structured in a very literal way. Cobb doesn't care about the spinning top because Cobbs totem was never the spinning top to begin with, it was Mals. I'm in no way saying Inception was bad. Good man :). You get Batman dueling it out with Wolverine, why aren't comic book fans salivating over this movie? In Inception, Cobb is overwhelmed by guilt over the loss of his wife Mal and blames himself for her death and the entire purpose of the film is to relieve Cobb of his guilt so he can get back to his children. r/StreamingMovieSitesHD: Movie Streaming Sites. I thought that it wasn't "set up" enough. Facebook Twitter Reddit Pinterest Email. I completely agree. Fuck me, right there, that was amazing. Comment. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. The Harry Potter movie The Prisoner of Azkaban couldn't include every detail from the book. And I like how Priest wrote about Nikola Tesla (who is (Tesla) my favourite historical figure, ever). It's lain out like a magic trick. And I seem to recall reading Nolan somewhere talking about Inception (the film itself) being a form of shared dream. begins with an array of identical hats strewn across the ground outdoors, and the voice of Alfred Borden asking if we are watching closely. :-). Saw the movie not so recently, but I have to agree with almost everyone, when I say I prefer actually movie. Book Vs Movie Podcast “The Prestige” Between the 1995 novel by Christopher Priest and the Christopher Nolan film. Adam C. Zern shares his thoughts on the film adaptation of Christopher Priest's The Prestige: "The Prestige the film is one of those films that many people remember to some degree—'oh, yeah, that magic movie'—but can't quite fill in the details. Let's get one thing out of the way: I preferred the movie. The Prestige gets right to the heart of why we even watch movies in the first place, and does so in a way that is both intellectually stimulating, deeply moving, and completely paradoxical. EDIT: wow, people don't seem to understand that this is an opinion of mine, not a fact that I am imposing upon everyone. Best shot in the whole film, if you ask me. Abracadabra! David Bowie playing Tesla. EDIT 2: I've never posted to /r/movies so I didn't know if this place was as susceptible to shitstorms as much as a place like r/gaming, so let me just be clear that I think both movies are very very good, The Prestige just appeals more to me (and, if I may be so bold, I really do think it is a bit more intelligent, but that's my opinion). I regard both of them as excellent films. Cobbs totem is in fact his Wedding Ring. The Margos get a little magical in this listener-suggested book to movie adaptation that features sleight of hand, lots of dead birds, women in jeopardy and a twist ending you either did or didn’t see coming a mile away. ‘The Prestige’ is not just a film about magic, it is a dark tale of bruised ego of men obsessed with secrets. To this day I don't know. I have the audiobook which I listened to after seeing the movie and found them more complementary to each other than a lot of movie/books. ", I don't miss a trick that often so thank you sir for enlightening...I always thought the boy had seen the switch and was referring to the BIRD'S double (corpse) makes so much more sense now you mention. It's a damn fine book that is more than able to stand on its own. Movie VS Book: The Prestige by Christopher Priest. This is a moderated subreddit. in regards to the bird-in-a-cage trick, because it is his double that particular day. unnecessary edit 3: there are comments that make the case far better than my post. Jonothan and Christopher Nolan changed a lot when they wrote the screen play, from the structure to the ending, even down to the focus of the story ie the mystery of the trick “The Disappearing Man” but every change they made works and I think improves the story. But I must ask you, are you watching closely? It's about a kid who commits a mass school shooting, told after the fact as … I really, really liked Inception, but I loved The Prestige. The whole he has a twin brother thing seemed to come out of nowhere. The definitive site for Reviews, Trailers, Showtimes, and Tickets http://www.chud.com/24477/never-wake-up-the-meaning-and-secret-of-inception/. A book is edited and crafted, but the writer is still working within an unlimited time canvas. It would have been nice to experience it without knowing what the hell was going on, but then I'm also glad to have had that experience with Christopher Nolan's version. I've watched it twice more since then. Very early on in Inception, we meet someone who becomes a recurring part of the film, Cobbs wife Mal. I just didn't like it. The Prestige was just brilliant. Reddit, are there any movies you like better than the books? People come out thinking they have seen a great movie having a great climax. This movie has all three. If you're looking for help with a personal book recommendation, consult our Weekly Recommendation Thread, Suggested Reading page, or ask in r/suggestmeabook. I don't want this to get buried, so I apologize for using your comment to do so. Nolan FTW. Share Share Tweet Email. Books to Movies: The Prestige vs. I thought it was more symbolic than the book. After two movies of sunny skies, Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban is a … It is the ability to go back and pick up on all the little details you may have missed along the way that makes it all the more wonderful and re-watchable, aside from of course everything else that is great about it... Well I'd like to share an idea with you... Perhaps we will go back to the moment you first finished watching Inception.